Actionable insights — Friday POW!: Macy's (M) 6.7% '34 bond
The repeatable analysis behind the pick: not what Haymaker bought, but how they hunt the BB sweet spot, stress-test the credit by asset coverage, and measure a bond's return against the stock market — written so each step can be rerun on the next issuer.
How to read this page: each insight is a method — the screen that surfaced the bond, the steps that confirmed the credit, and the signal to watch when re-running it on another name. The boxed line shows how it played out in this post. (Written newsletter — "read" links open the source post; no timestamps.)
1. Hunt the BB "sweet spot" — buy default-resistant credit at high-yield coupons
The repeatable method
- Screen corporate bonds for the BB / BB+ band — one notch below investment grade — where the "BB anomaly" lives: historic default rates under 1% annually, yet coupons that pay a high-yield premium.
- Confirm the yield is genuinely "juicy" relative to the risk-free curve: compute the yield-to-maturity from coupon, current price and maturity, then check the spread over a comparable-maturity Treasury (demand a few hundred basis points of excess).
- Treat the rating as the entry filter, not the whole thesis — a BB+ that you can independently show is over-collateralized (next insight) is a fallen angel in waiting, not a junk bond.
Here: the M 6.7% note due 7/15/2034, BB+, at 95.474 → 7.45% YTM, ~290bp over the 2036 UST — "our favorite slice of the corporate bond market."
Watch for
- BB/BB+ issuers trading below par so the YTM exceeds the coupon; a spread wide enough to pay you for a default risk the fundamentals say is overstated.
2. Stress-test the credit by asset coverage — real estate vs market cap vs debt
The repeatable method
- Don't stop at the income statement: find a third-party appraisal of the issuer's hard assets (CoStar for real estate, here $7.9–10.5B) and compare it to both the equity market cap and the total debt.
- Require the asset value to exceed the debt (ideally with a margin) so bondholders are covered even in a liquidation — and note when assets exceed the entire stock-market value, signalling the equity market is ignoring them.
- Layer the balance sheet on top: cash on hand, net debt, and the trend in free cash flow — a credit paying down debt is upgrading itself underneath you.
Here: M's real estate ($7.9–10.5B) tops its $6.5B market cap and covers its $5.1B debt; ~$1.3B cash, ~$3.8B net debt, FCF up double-digits two years running.
Watch for
- Asset-rich, multiple-poor issuers where appraised property covers the debt several times over; FCF growth that gives the company optionality to retire the bonds early.
3. Use insider / Buffett-grade validation as a confirming data point, not the thesis
The repeatable method
- Check whether a credible, long-horizon buyer has recently taken a stake — a Berkshire-type purchase is "a vote of confidence consistent with an operating turnaround."
- Size the signal honestly: a 1% / $55M position is "walking around money," so weight it as corroboration of the cash-flow story, not as the reason to buy.
- For a bond buyer, read an equity purchase as confirmation the enterprise is healthy enough to keep servicing debt — the equity sits junior to your claim, so its sponsor's confidence reinforces your safety.
Here: Berkshire (now run by Greg Abel) bought ~1% of M shares (~$55M) — small, but "a nice vote of confidence."
Watch for
- A respected long-term holder initiating a position in the equity of a company whose bonds you're underwriting; treat it as one input, never the trigger.
4. Demand a Change-of-Control put — turn LBO risk into an LBO gain
The repeatable method
- Before buying any below-IG corporate bond, read the indenture for a Change-of-Control (CoC) provision — LBOs are "anathema to bondholders" because they trigger downgrades and steep price drops.
- Require the covenant to let holders put the bond back to the issuer at a premium to par on a change of control, so a buyout becomes a profit rather than a loss given a sub-par purchase price.
- Quantify that protection at your entry price: the lower below par you buy, the larger the built-in gain if the put is ever exercised.
Here: the M note's CoC provision lets holders sell back at a slight premium to par — a gain from the recent $95.474 price if an LBO occurs.
Watch for
- A CoC / "poison put" clause priced near or below par; avoid otherwise-attractive bonds that lack it, since LBO chatter alone can crater an unprotected note.
5. Benchmark the bond against the stock market's likely forward return
The repeatable method
- Frame the buy decision not just "is this a safe yield?" but "does this contractual return beat what equities are likely to deliver over the same horizon?"
- When the equity index looks expensive / late-cycle, a covered ~7½% locked yield to a fixed maturity can win on a risk-adjusted and absolute basis — a defined, senior claim versus an uncertain total return.
- State the horizon explicitly (here, "the rest of the decade … maybe out to the 2034 maturity") so the comparison is apples-to-apples against a buy-and-hold equity allocation.
Here: Haymaker's "neck-sticking-out" call — the M bond's return has "a good chance" of beating the S&P 500 total return over the rest of the decade.
Watch for
- Stretched equity valuations where a senior, asset-covered ~7½% to maturity rivals plausible stock returns; lock the yield while it's on offer rather than reaching for index upside.
Methods distilled from the paid Haymaker newsletter (text in transcript.txt) for personal study. Not investment advice. © Haymaker / David Hay for source material.