← Analysis page  ·  David Hay hub  ·  Research hub

Actionable insights — Friday POW!: Macy's (M) 6.7% '34 bond

The repeatable analysis behind the pick: not what Haymaker bought, but how they hunt the BB sweet spot, stress-test the credit by asset coverage, and measure a bond's return against the stock market — written so each step can be rerun on the next issuer.
2026-JUN-19 · Haymaker (Substack newsletter, paid) · The Haymaker Team / David Hay · ↗ Read · full analysis · article text
How to read this page: each insight is a method — the screen that surfaced the bond, the steps that confirmed the credit, and the signal to watch when re-running it on another name. The boxed line shows how it played out in this post. (Written newsletter — "read" links open the source post; no timestamps.)

1. Hunt the BB "sweet spot" — buy default-resistant credit at high-yield coupons

The repeatable method
  1. Screen corporate bonds for the BB / BB+ band — one notch below investment grade — where the "BB anomaly" lives: historic default rates under 1% annually, yet coupons that pay a high-yield premium.
  2. Confirm the yield is genuinely "juicy" relative to the risk-free curve: compute the yield-to-maturity from coupon, current price and maturity, then check the spread over a comparable-maturity Treasury (demand a few hundred basis points of excess).
  3. Treat the rating as the entry filter, not the whole thesis — a BB+ that you can independently show is over-collateralized (next insight) is a fallen angel in waiting, not a junk bond.
Here: the M 6.7% note due 7/15/2034, BB+, at 95.474 → 7.45% YTM, ~290bp over the 2036 UST — "our favorite slice of the corporate bond market."
Watch for

2. Stress-test the credit by asset coverage — real estate vs market cap vs debt

The repeatable method
  1. Don't stop at the income statement: find a third-party appraisal of the issuer's hard assets (CoStar for real estate, here $7.9–10.5B) and compare it to both the equity market cap and the total debt.
  2. Require the asset value to exceed the debt (ideally with a margin) so bondholders are covered even in a liquidation — and note when assets exceed the entire stock-market value, signalling the equity market is ignoring them.
  3. Layer the balance sheet on top: cash on hand, net debt, and the trend in free cash flow — a credit paying down debt is upgrading itself underneath you.
Here: M's real estate ($7.9–10.5B) tops its $6.5B market cap and covers its $5.1B debt; ~$1.3B cash, ~$3.8B net debt, FCF up double-digits two years running.
Watch for

3. Use insider / Buffett-grade validation as a confirming data point, not the thesis

The repeatable method
  1. Check whether a credible, long-horizon buyer has recently taken a stake — a Berkshire-type purchase is "a vote of confidence consistent with an operating turnaround."
  2. Size the signal honestly: a 1% / $55M position is "walking around money," so weight it as corroboration of the cash-flow story, not as the reason to buy.
  3. For a bond buyer, read an equity purchase as confirmation the enterprise is healthy enough to keep servicing debt — the equity sits junior to your claim, so its sponsor's confidence reinforces your safety.
Here: Berkshire (now run by Greg Abel) bought ~1% of M shares (~$55M) — small, but "a nice vote of confidence."
Watch for

4. Demand a Change-of-Control put — turn LBO risk into an LBO gain

The repeatable method
  1. Before buying any below-IG corporate bond, read the indenture for a Change-of-Control (CoC) provision — LBOs are "anathema to bondholders" because they trigger downgrades and steep price drops.
  2. Require the covenant to let holders put the bond back to the issuer at a premium to par on a change of control, so a buyout becomes a profit rather than a loss given a sub-par purchase price.
  3. Quantify that protection at your entry price: the lower below par you buy, the larger the built-in gain if the put is ever exercised.
Here: the M note's CoC provision lets holders sell back at a slight premium to par — a gain from the recent $95.474 price if an LBO occurs.
Watch for

5. Benchmark the bond against the stock market's likely forward return

The repeatable method
  1. Frame the buy decision not just "is this a safe yield?" but "does this contractual return beat what equities are likely to deliver over the same horizon?"
  2. When the equity index looks expensive / late-cycle, a covered ~7½% locked yield to a fixed maturity can win on a risk-adjusted and absolute basis — a defined, senior claim versus an uncertain total return.
  3. State the horizon explicitly (here, "the rest of the decade … maybe out to the 2034 maturity") so the comparison is apples-to-apples against a buy-and-hold equity allocation.
Here: Haymaker's "neck-sticking-out" call — the M bond's return has "a good chance" of beating the S&P 500 total return over the rest of the decade.
Watch for

Methods distilled from the paid Haymaker newsletter (text in transcript.txt) for personal study. Not investment advice. © Haymaker / David Hay for source material.