← Analysis page  ·  David Hay hub  ·  Research hub

Actionable insights — EQT (EQT): the unhedged-call-option screen

The repeatable analysis behind the pick: not what they bought, but how they found it — written so the process can be rerun later on other commodity-leverage and deleveraging plays.
2026-MAR-20 · Haymaker — Friday POW! · The Haymaker Team / David Hay · ↗ Read · full analysis · article text
How to read this page: each insight is a method — the trigger that surfaced the idea, the lens used, and the signal to watch when re-running it. The boxed line shows how it played out with EQT. (Written post, no video — no timestamps.)

1. Hunt the unhedged producer into a supply shock — maximize price leverage

The repeatable method
  1. When a commodity supply shock hits, screen producers by their hedge book: an unhedged producer captures 100% of the price spike (a hedged peer gives most of it away).
  2. Confirm the leverage math: with all output unhedged, every incremental dollar of realized price drops straight to free cash flow — the equity behaves like a "pure, unlevered call option" on the commodity.
  3. Prefer the lowest-cost, highest-volume operator in the basin so the leverage compounds on the largest base.
Here: EQT — entirely unhedged for 2026, the largest/lowest-cost Appalachian producer, into the Hormuz + Qatar-force-majeure LNG shock.
Watch for

2. Buy the stale guidance — when the macro moved after the number was set

The repeatable method
  1. Check the date a FCF/earnings guide was set against the date of a subsequent macro move (a price spike, a supply event).
  2. A guide set at lower strip prices before the shock is conservative-by-construction — the realized number should beat it materially.
  3. Underwrite the upside to the post-shock environment, not the stale guide the consensus is still anchored to.
Here: EQT's ~$3.3B 2026 FCF guide (~8% yield) was set before Qatar's force majeure and the Hormuz LNG-price jump — so it understates the unhedged upside.
Watch for

3. The deleveraging re-rating — equity's claim grows as debt comes off

The repeatable method
  1. Map the net-debt trajectory (here $9.1B → $7.7B → target ~$4.7B) and note that at high EBITDA margins, debt paydown accelerates with the commodity price.
  2. Recognize that on a fixed enterprise value, every dollar of debt repaid transfers value to equity — the equity re-rates even if the multiple doesn't.
  3. Value the company for what its balance sheet will look like in 12–24 months ($4–5B net debt), not where it is today.
Here: EQT ~67% EBITDA margin, cutting ~$3B of net debt in a single year — "the market is only beginning to re-rate EQT for what it will look like at $4-5B net debt."
Watch for

4. The operational-quality tell — beat on output while spending less

The repeatable method
  1. Look past the headline EPS beat to the operational mix: volumes above the high end of guidance and capex below the midpoint and unit costs at the low end.
  2. That combination — more output for less spend — is the signature of a genuinely well-run producer and drives sustained FCF outperformance, not a one-quarter fluke.
  3. Require a track record (beats in each of the last four quarters) before trusting the guide.
Here: EQT Q4 volume 609 BCF above the high end, capex $655M 4% below midpoint, unit costs at the low end — "producing more than expected while spending less."
Watch for

5. The all-prior-resistance breakout — confirm the fundamental call with the long chart

The repeatable method
  1. Pull the longest available chart and check whether the move has cleared every prior resistance level, including the all-time high (here back through 2014–2015).
  2. Treat an "upside range expansion" above all historical supply as Haymaker's high-conviction technical signal — there are no trapped sellers overhead.
  3. Require the breakout to coincide with the fundamentals (cheap valuation, accelerating earnings, clean balance sheet) for the strongest setup.
Here: EQT eclipsed its 2014 ATH and took out resistance back to 2015 — "broken out above all prior resistance levels," with RRC / DVN showing the same pattern and the XLE at record highs.
Watch for

6. Stress-test the unhedged bet with the prior trough

The repeatable method
  1. State the bear case plainly (the commodity reverses — here Henry Hub back toward $3 against the unhedged book) and don't dismiss it.
  2. Quantify the floor by checking what the company earned at the last price trough (EQT made $879M FCF in 2023 with gas at $2.74).
  3. Identify the structural demand floor (LNG exports, data-center power, electrification) that didn't exist in prior cycles, then size the position accordingly — start smaller after a run-up, add on weakness.
Here: EQT's downside is anchored by its 2023 trough FCF; Haymaker buys a smaller initial position post-breakout and adds on retracements toward $58–60.
Watch for

Methods distilled from the paid Haymaker newsletter (text in transcript.txt) for personal study. Not investment advice. © Haymaker / David Hay for source material.