← Analysis page  ·  David Hay hub  ·  Research hub

Actionable insights — Portfolio Update: Double Follow-Up

This page is not about that Haymaker still likes GNRC and EQT. It is about the checks behind those calls: how to read the structure of a customer contract, how to tell a justified multiple from a mispriced cycle, how to treat stale analyst targets after a material event, how to use a stock's own pull-back rhythm, and how to find a cheap proxy for an expensive theme. Each is written so it can be rerun.
2026-SEP-21 · Haymaker (Substack newsletter, paid) · The Haymaker Team / David Hay · Monday Portfolio Update · ↗ Read · full analysis · article text
How to read this page: each insight is a method, and the boxed line shows how it played out in this post. This is a written newsletter, so there are no timestamps; the "read" link opens the source post.

1. Grade a big customer contract by its incentive structure, not its headline size

The repeatable method
  1. When a supplier announces a large customer deal, read the 8-K for what the customer gets, not just the dollar ceiling.
  2. Is the customer given equity or warrants that vest in proportion to its purchases? If so, it profits from the supplier's stock and has a reason to keep ordering.
  3. Check whether any of it vested at signing. That separates a committed relationship from a letter of intent or a "preferred vendor" status.
  4. Split the ceiling into near-term committed deliveries and the long tail, and model only the committed part.
Here: GNRCAMZN: up to $8B through 2033, with $2.4B in 2027–28 deliveries. Amazon may buy up to 1.7M shares at $200.93 "only as it actually places orders," and part vested at signing. "That alignment is the moat."
Watch for

2. Anchor today's multiple to what the market was paying for at the old peak

The repeatable method
  1. Pull the 10-year forward P/E and P/S chart. Note the peak and what drove earnings at the time.
  2. If the peak priced temporary (cyclical or pandemic) demand as if it were permanent, treat it as a mistake, not a benchmark.
  3. Compare today's multiple with the long-run range excluding that episode, and ask whether today's earnings are more durable (contracted, recurring) than the earnings at the peak.
  4. A multiple near the historical norm on more durable earnings is under-priced even if it looks "fair."
Here: GNRC paid 42× forward / ~10× sales in 2021 for "a cyclical demand story priced as a secular one." Today it is 17.9× / 2.76×, ~57% below that peak, on a data-center business that is "structurally different."
Watch for

3. Mark analyst targets as stale after a material event

The repeatable method
  1. Note the date of the latest consensus targets against the date of the material filing (contract, guidance change).
  2. If the targets predate the event, treat the average as a floor, and the highest pre-event targets as the likely new center.
  3. Expect revisions over the following weeks, with the next earnings call as the formal catalyst.
Here: the GNRC average of $284–$295 "was set before September 16th," and none of those models included the Amazon agreement. "UBS at $340 and Jefferies at $338… may no longer be the outliers."
Watch for

4. Buy the stock's own pull-back rhythm when the breakout is incomplete

The repeatable method
  1. Where a stock has broken out but not cleared the long-term range, look for a series of higher highs.
  2. Measure the pull-back after each high. If past pull-backs were later rewarded, treat the next one as the add point.
  3. Build or add in the pull-back rather than chasing the high.
Here: GNRC made "a steady series of higher highs… after each of those, it has had a material pull-back, as it did this summer. These have been opportune times to build, or build-up, a position."
Watch for

5. Own the input to an expensive theme instead of the theme's leaders

The repeatable method
  1. For a hot theme (AI), list its physical inputs (power, then fuel for that power).
  2. Find the largest low-cost producer of that input trading at a discount to the market.
  3. Quantify incoming demand in physical units (GW of plants under construction or planned) and compare local prices with world prices to size the upside.
  4. Look for committed third-party capital (e.g., foreign-funded plants) near the producer's footprint as the catalyst.
Here: EQT at 12.4× P/E (~40% below the S&P) is "among the best AI plays" for those averse to "lofty prices." ~50 GW of gas plants are planned, and US gas is ~$3 vs >$20 in Europe and Asia. Japan's ~18 GW includes a 9.2 GW plant in Portsmouth, Ohio, in or near EQT's footprint.
Watch for

Methods distilled from the paid Haymaker newsletter (Sep 21, 2026) for personal study. Not investment advice.