1. Triangulate forward inventories to front-run the draw
The repeatable method
- Don't wait for the weekly DOE print — build a forward picture of inventories from independent data: producer output data, announced refinery runs, ship/tanker signaling (boats heading to the Gulf of America), and import/export flows.
- Net the supply against the demand side to project where stockpiles land weeks ahead — the draw is visible before it shows up in the headline number.
- Lean on the rare desks that actually do this work (energy talent is thin after 15 years as a 3-4% index backwater; he names HFI Research, Energy Aspects, Sparta, Kayrros as the sources he cross-checks).
Here: producer + refinery-run + ship-signaling checks projected the largest US crude draws "in the history of the data" over a 6-8 week window — and Cushing tank bottoms by ~June 30 — well before the market priced it.
Watch for
- Refinery runs rising, imports falling, exports rising simultaneously (the three accelerants); tanker counts to the US Gulf; the weekly DOE confirming the forward model.
2. Separate inventory destocking from real demand destruction
The repeatable method
- When you see declining imports, don't assume demand is falling — falling imports can simply mean a country is drawing down stock (destocking) rather than consuming less.
- Cross-check consumption with hard activity data (connected-vehicle / transaction counts), not just headline volumes; global import declines are backward-looking and partial.
- Deflate any spending-based demand read by price. A "-3% y/y" gasoline figure built from credit-card spend overstates the drop: when prices spike, consumers buy at cheaper stations and lower grades, and more pay cash inside to dodge the >3% card fee — all of which depresses card spend without depressing real demand.
Here: bears read declining imports + a card-spend "-3%" as demand destruction; Paulo showed imports bottomed in May and rebounded, station transaction counts stayed firm, and the spend drop was a price/behavior artifact — so the bearish demand story was actually a bullish destocking story.
Watch for
- Import troughs that turn up; transaction counts diverging from dollar spend; analysts citing card-spend without price-deflating it.
3. Use operational-minimum tank bottoms as the shortage trigger
The repeatable method
- Know the floor for each inventory: physical minimums you can't draw below — linefill, minimum refinery stocks, tank deadstock. (US commercial crude ~370mmbbls; Cushing ~17-20mmbbls; gasoline ~200mmbbls; distillates ~100-110mmbbls.)
- Project the draw path toward those floors; the moment stocks approach the operational minimum without demand destruction is when outright shortages / fueling lines become possible — a step-change, not a gradual tightening.
- Respect the sequence: the inventory nearest its floor breaks first. Gasoline (esp. PADD1 / East Coast) leads crude by weeks.
Here: Cushing projected to hit tank bottoms ~June 30; gasoline approaching its ~200mmbbls minimum → "very possible" PADD1 fueling lines by end-June, with crude the obvious problem only weeks behind.
Watch for
- Cushing nearing 17-20mmbbls; PADD1 gasoline nearing operational minimum; SPR discharge rates degrading as the caverns deplete (the DOE's own T4 RFP warning).
4. Spot the futures→options→dealer-short-gamma squeeze setup
The repeatable method
- After a VaR shock, watch whether participants degross and shift from futures into options (to cap stop-out risk) — that thins prompt-futures liquidity and pushes the risk onto dealers.
- If that flow leaves market makers short calls, and volatility is low, you have squeeze fuel: a rally forces dealers to buy futures into an illiquid market to hedge rising delta and vanna, accelerating the move (the same mechanic as the semiconductor delta/vanna squeeze).
- Confirm the powder is dry by checking that outright speculative net-long is low — if the elevated net-long is mostly options exposure, a pop on dealer hedging is more violent, not less.
Here: degrossed physical traders flipped futures into options → dealers short calls in illiquid prompt crude; WTI spec net-long near 2023-24 lows with the length sitting in options — the convex squeeze setup behind the BNO call position.
Watch for
- Thinning prompt-futures liquidity; rising option open interest vs futures; low realized vol; spec net-long near multi-year lows while options length stays elevated.
5. Fade crowded retail positioning in a broken inverse ETF
The repeatable method
- Find the leveraged/inverse ETF the retail crowd is using to express the opposite of your view, and track its asset/flow trajectory, not just its price.
- Read persistent inflows into a structurally decaying product (a -2× daily inverse fund) despite heavy losses as a one-sided, over-positioned sentiment extreme — contrarian fuel for the move they're fighting.
- Cross-check against the "smart" side: who's on the other side of the trade in the CoT data?
Here: SCO (-2× WTI) assets exploded $100mn → ~$1.5bn (~$1.6bn inflows since the war) while -65% YTD — retail crowding the short — even as producer/merchant commercials went heavily net long in the CoT and swap dealers blew out to ~660k net short.
Watch for
- Inflows into an inverse/levered ETF that keeps losing; CoT producer/merchant net-long rising while "other reportable" cuts length; commercials (Exxon/Chevron commentary) buying what synthetics sell.
6. Separate "inevitable" from "imminent" — then size for the convergence
The repeatable method
- Distinguish a thesis that is baked-in / inevitable (the math can't avoid it) from one that is imminent (about to be marked). They're often not the same — the gap is the "frustration window" where you can be right and still marked against you (the Big Short analogy).
- Express an inevitable-but-not-yet-imminent view with convex, time-tolerant structures — long-dated calls with positive carry (roll yield in backwardation) — so the wait costs little and the payoff is outsized.
- Watch for the catalyst that collapses the gap (a non-linear "oh sh*t" awareness moment), and re-size as "weeks/months" compresses to "days/weeks."
Here: historic US draws judged inevitable for months but the timing finally converged — so he sized BNO calls across Jul-26→Jan-27 strikes (roll yield pays the wait) as his largest position, "bought aggressively as recently as Friday."
Watch for
- A single visible catalyst ("Tom Hanks has Covid" moment); the draw appearing in the weekly print; backwardation deepening so the call structure earns carry while you wait.
7. Discount the headline driver everyone is trading
The repeatable method
- When a geopolitical headline (here, Iran / the Strait of Hormuz) dominates the tape, test whether your thesis actually needs it — run the numbers with the headline risk fully removed.
- If the conclusion holds either way, treat the headline as noise and ignore the crowd waiting for a "deal" / dip — "when everyone is waiting for something, the market won't let them in."
Here: the thesis pre-dated Iran (formed in January); US commercial inventories head below 400mmbbls "even if the Strait opens tomorrow" — so a peace-deal/TACO dip would just remove the geopolitics and leave the bullish inventory math standing.
Watch for
- Consensus positioned for a headline-driven dip that never comes; the math being unchanged in your "what if the risk resolves benignly?" scenario.