← Pieter Slegers hub  ·  Research hub  ·  Research library

Pieter Slegers — Best Buys: May 2026

Five ranked buys — KKR, 3i Group, MSCI, Hermès and a FICO down 55% on a regulatory decision — plus a spotlight on QXO, Brad Jacobs' $30bn-in-12-months building-products roll-up and its $17bn TopBuild acquisition.
2026-MAY-03 · Compounding Quality (Substack) · Pieter Slegers / Team Compounding Quality · written post (monthly Best Buys, from Omaha) · read ↗ · transcript · actionable insights
One-line take: the monthly ranking lands five days after the 28 April shortlist and confirms it almost exactly — KKR #1, 3i Group #2, MSCI #3, FICO #5, four of the five names carried straight over, with Hermès inserted at #4. The month's headline event is a live test of a moat: FICO is down over 55% from its peak because in April the FHFA "announced they are officially moving forward with VantageScore 4.0" as a mortgage-underwriting alternative — a regulatory monopoly attacked by the regulator that created it. The rebuttal is three specific points rather than a shrug: lenders will pull both scores because "in lending, more data beats different data"; switching means "a multi-year infrastructure overhaul most banks won't risk" given how deeply regulations and internal risk models are wired to FICO; and the price complaint is trivial — "FICO's price hikes are negligible on a $500K mortgage." Results reported "earlier this week" are taken as confirmation: "it seems like the investment thesis is not broken after all." The QXO spotlight is the most transferable section: Brad Jacobs' three-step consolidation formula — find a fragmented, analog industry; raise capital and buy the anchors; then apply technology — run before at United Waste (sold for $2.5bn), United Rentals and XPO Logistics (revenue $175m → $15bn), and now at QXO, which has spent over $30bn on acquisitions in twelve months in an $800bn market. The $17bn TopBuild deal is the case study: +$6.2bn of revenue, 400+ locations, $300m of expected synergies by 2030, and — the number that matters — a margin step-up, since TopBuild's ~18% adjusted EBITDA margin against QXO's ~8% takes the combined company to ~12%. Elsewhere, 3i is down nearly 50% from its highs on French like-for-like growth slowing to 2% and a €400m plan to take Action to the US Southeast in late 2027 — treated as "essentially a free call option" on top of a NAV discount — while KKR is down ~50% with insiders "aggressively buying": "there are lots of reasons for insiders to sell, but there's only one reason they buy."

1. Stocks & names mentioned

Five ranked buys, one spotlight and its acquisition target, the two monthly performance tables, and the companies named as evidence for Brad Jacobs' record. Portfolio holdings are deliberately excluded from the ranking — "please note that the companies in Our Portfolio are not mentioned here. We love all companies in Our Portfolio right now." Research legend: QT Qualtrim · SA Seeking Alpha · STK Stock Analysis. Written post with no timestamps — the At link opens the article.

TickerNameResearchViewWhat he saidAt
KKRKKR & Co.QT · SA · STK · FAPositiveBest Buy #1. "KKR proves that size is a moat in private equity", with nearly $750bn of AUM. Three supports: a record $129bn raised in 2025 while "smaller firms struggle to raise capital in a high-interest-rate environment"; roughly $126bn of dry powder — "in a market where assets are getting cheaper, KKR is ready to buy"; and the insider signal — "despite the stock being down ~50% from its highs, insiders have been aggressively buying shares. There are lots of reasons for insiders to sell, but there's only one reason they buy. The stock is cheap." Summarised as "an alternative asset manager with permanent insurance capital." Also April's best performer at +12.8%.read ↗
III.L3i Group plcQT · SA · STKPositiveBest Buy #2. "3i Group is essentially an investment in Action, the European discount retailer." Action grew sales to €16bn in 2025 while the stock dropped nearly 50% from its highs, for two named reasons: French like-for-like growth — its second-largest market — slowing to 2%, raising saturation fears; and a €400m plan to take Action to the United States (the Southeast, late 2027), with investors worried it "will become the next 'Lidl' or 'Tesco' and fail to catch on in America." The defence is the model: "Action's 'Scale Economies Shared' model is incredibly resilient. It's exactly the same model that made companies like Amazon and Costco so successful." And the structure of the opportunity: "you are getting the European business at a bargain, and the US expansion is essentially a free call option", on top of a clear discount to NAV.read ↗
MSCIMSCI Inc.QT · SA · STK · FAPositiveBest Buy #3. "MSCI continues to be the Toll Bridge of the global investment industry", earning both asset-based fees on every ETF tracking an MSCI index and high-margin data subscriptions. Q1 2026 revenue $850.8m, up from $745.8m. The AI fear is named and answered in one line: "creating an index is easy, but creating an index that every pension fund and bank in the world trusts and has integrated into their software for 30 years is nearly impossible." Also classified as a Cannibal Stock — free cash flow spent on buybacks, "meaning your ownership of the business just gets bigger and bigger."read ↗
RMS.PAHermès InternationalQT · SA · STKPositiveBest Buy #4, and the one name not carried over from the April shortlist. Segments given: Leather Goods and Saddlery ~43% of revenue, Ready-to-wear and Accessories ~28%, Other ~29%. 2025: revenue €16bn, +9% at constant rates, with a 41% operating margin. The economic label is the useful part: "Hermès is the ultimate Veblen Good. This means that as the price goes up, the demand increases because the prestige grows." Three supports — the waitlist, vertical integration "from the tanneries to the workshops", and a customer base that holds up in downturns: "that's why Hermès is often the last luxury brand to feel a slowdown and the first to recover." Upgraded Sell→Hold four days later on 7 May.read ↗
FICOFair Isaac CorporationQT · SA · STK · FAPositiveBest Buy #5, and the month's live moat test. "FICO is down over 55% (!) from its peak. What happened? In April, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) announced they are officially moving forward with VantageScore 4.0… as an alternative to FICO for mortgage underwriting." Three-part rebuttal: (1) "even if lenders add VantageScore, they'll still pull FICO alongside it. In lending, more data beats different data"; (2) "regulations and internal risk models are deeply tied to FICO. Switching means a multi-year infrastructure overhaul most banks won't risk"; (3) "FICO's price hikes are negligible on a $500K mortgage. Lenders care about predictive accuracy, and FICO 10T is still the gold standard." Now "very close to the lowest Forward P/E we've seen in a decade", and "earlier this week, FICO reported great results. It seems like the investment thesis is not broken after all." Upgraded Hold→Buy on 7 May.read ↗
QXOQXO, Inc.QT · SA · STK · FAPositiveThe monthly spotlight (and April's #5 performer at +10.2%). A building-products distributor "acting as the middleman between manufacturers and contractors", now #1 in insulation, #2 in roofing, #1 in waterproofing and #1 or #2 in lumber and building materials after the TopBuild deal. The case is the founder: Brad Jacobs, "one of the most successful serial consolidators in business history", eight billion-dollar companies, and a three-step formula — find a fragmented, analog industry of "thousands of small, local players using outdated technology"; "buy the anchors" with capital raised upfront for immediate scale; then apply technology, as with AI truck-routing at XPO and centralised pricing and inventory across 1,150+ locations at QXO. Scale of the attempt: over $30bn of acquisitions in twelve months in an $800bn industry. Closing: "we love businesses that sell essential products with high switching costs led by world-class management."read ↗
BLDTopBuild Corp.QT · SA · STKPositiveThe $17bn acquisition announced in April 2026 and "the biggest catalyst for QXO". "TopBuild is the largest distributor and installer of insulation and related building products in North America"; the stock is up +444% since 2020 with attractive revenue and EPS growth, and the author discloses prior familiarity — "I used to follow it when I was involved in the daily management of a Climate Fund." Deal terms: +$6.2bn annual revenue, 400+ locations, $300m of expected annual synergies by 2030, making QXO the #2 building-products distributor in North America. The margin arithmetic is the point: QXO's ~8% adjusted EBITDA margin against TopBuild's ~18%, combining to an estimated ~12%.read ↗
ANETArista NetworksQT · SA · STK · FANeutralThe month's best performer in the investable universe at +40.7%. Listed in the performance table only — no thesis, no valuation, no rating.read ↗
NSPInsperityQT · SA · STK · FANeutralSecond-best performer of the month at +31.5%. Performance table only; no view expressed.read ↗
NVONovo NordiskQT · SA · STK · FANeutralThird-best performer at +17.9% — a notable turn for a name called a cheapness-driven "mistake" five days earlier. Performance table only; the substantive update comes on 7 May.read ↗
EPAMEPAM SystemsQT · SA · STK · FANeutralWorst performer of the month at -15.9%. Performance table only. Framed positively by the section's standing line: "the cheaper we can buy great companies, the better."read ↗
CSGPCoStar GroupQT · SA · STK · FANeutralSecond-worst performer at -14.2%. Performance table only; no thesis given here. Also the second-worst YTD name on the 7 May watchlist at -47.1%.read ↗
MEDPMedpace HoldingsQT · SA · STK · FANeutralThird-worst performer at -12.8%, and a Very Strong conviction holding — so excluded from the ranking by the issue's own rule. Performance table only.read ↗
BROBrown & BrownQT · SA · STK · FANeutralFourth-worst performer at -7.7% — during the same month it was bought for $15,000 at a $63 limit. Performance table only; no fresh view.read ↗
KPG.AXKelly Partners Group HoldingsSTKNeutralFifth-worst performer at -7.2%. Performance table only; no fresh view. The worst YTD name on the 7 May watchlist at -48.8%.read ↗
XPOXPO, Inc.QT · SA · STK · FANeutralCited as evidence for the QXO thesis, not as a recommendation: Brad Jacobs' 2011 vehicle, which "grew revenue from $175 million to $15 billion", and where "he used AI to optimize truck routes" — the technology step of the three-part formula.read ↗
URIUnited RentalsQT · SA · STK · FANeutralCited as track-record evidence: Jacobs' 1997 venture, where he "built the world's largest equipment rental company from scratch". No stance on the company today.read ↗
EFXEquifaxQT · SA · STK · FANeutralNamed as one of the three credit bureaus FICO licenses its algorithm to. No stance — the bureaus are FICO's distribution channel and, through their VantageScore joint venture, also its challenger.read ↗
EXPN.LExperian plcSA · STKNeutralNamed as the second of the three credit bureaus licensing the FICO score. No stance.read ↗
TRUTransUnionQT · SA · STK · FANeutralNamed as the third credit bureau licensing the FICO score. No stance.read ↗
privateActionPositivePrivate; 3i Group's crown jewel and the whole of its Best Buy case. Sales of €16bn in 2025. The two worries: French like-for-like growth slowing to 2%, and a €400m US expansion targeting the Southeast in late 2027 that the market fears will fail as other European retailers have. The defence is the operating model — "Scale Economies Shared… exactly the same model that made companies like Amazon and Costco so successful" — and the framing is that you pay for Europe and get America free.read ↗

Two data notes. (1) The performance graphics are mislabelled. Both the best- and worst-performer cards are titled "March 2026" while the surrounding text discusses April ("The S&P 500 rose by 9.7% in April… here are the worst performers of the past month"), so the graphic template appears not to have been updated. The names and percentages are transcribed as published. (2) The April index return is quoted twice, differently. This issue says the S&P 500 "rose by 9.7% in April"; the 7 May issue says "the S&P 500 rose 9.6% in April" — a 10bp discrepancy, most likely a total-return versus price-return difference. Also worth noting on ranking discipline: the issue explicitly excludes portfolio holdings from the Best Buys ("we love all companies in Our Portfolio right now"), so the list is a watchlist ranking rather than a whole-universe one — which is why MEDP, BRO and KPG.AX appear in the worst-performer table but not in the top five.

2. Talking points

FICO — a regulatory moat attacked by the regulator

Brad Jacobs' three-step formula, stated as a reusable process

The TopBuild deal — margin, not just scale

3i Group — paying for Europe, getting America free

KKR — three independent reasons, one of them behavioural

Hermès — the Veblen good, and the recovery order

MSCI — an index as a coordination standard

The month's context

3. In plain English

A jargon-free summary of the thesis behind each argued name. (Renders on each name's consolidated page.)

KKR — KKR & Co. Positive

KKR is the month's number one pick. It invests institutional money — pension funds, insurers — in companies, infrastructure and private lending, and now looks after nearly $750 billion.

The argument is that in this industry, being big is itself the advantage. When money is expensive and investors are cautious, smaller firms cannot raise new funds at all; KKR raised a record $129 billion last year. It also has about $126 billion of uncommitted cash sitting ready, which is worth a great deal precisely when asset prices are falling.

The share price is down about half from its high on worries about private credit. The signal offered against that is insider behaviour: executives have been buying heavily. As the write-up puts it, there are many reasons an insider might sell — a house, a divorce, a tax bill — but only one reason to buy.

III.L — 3i Group Positive

3i Group is really one investment: Action, the European discount chain, which sold €16 billion of goods in 2025. The shares have nonetheless fallen nearly 50% from their high.

Two things spooked investors. Sales growth in France, Action's second-biggest market, slowed to 2%, which raised the fear that Europe is filling up. And 3i committed €400 million to launching Action in the American Southeast in late 2027 — and European retailers have a poor record in America; Tesco's attempt failed expensively.

The counter-argument is about the business model. Action buys in enormous volume, passes the savings to customers as lower prices, attracts more shoppers, and buys in even greater volume — a cycle known as scale economies shared, and the same one that built Amazon and Costco. It does not stop working because one country's growth slows for a year.

The neat way of framing the opportunity: the shares trade below the stated value of what 3i owns, so you are buying the European business at a discount and getting the American venture thrown in for nothing. If it works, that is a large bonus; if it fails, you have not paid for it.

MSCI — MSCI Inc. Positive

MSCI creates the stock market indexes that funds are measured against, and charges a small fee on every dollar tracking one — more than $18 trillion in total. It also sells data and analytics software to the same customers, which is the higher-margin half.

Investors have marked the shares down on the fear that artificial intelligence will let any firm build its own indexes. The answer given is precise: building an index is trivial, and always was. What is not trivial is getting every pension fund and bank in the world to trust yours, and to have wired it into their systems for thirty years. That is the actual product.

The business is not slowing: revenue in the first quarter of 2026 was $850.8 million against $745.8 million a year earlier. And MSCI spends its considerable spare cash buying back its own shares, so an investor who does nothing owns a slightly larger slice of the company each year.

RMS.PA — Hermès International Positive

Hermès makes Birkin and Kelly handbags, silk, watches and perfume, and deliberately makes fewer of the famous items than people want. Leather goods are about 43% of sales, clothing and accessories 28%, and everything else 29%. In 2025 it sold €16 billion, growing 9%, and kept 41 cents of every euro as operating profit — an extraordinary margin for a manufacturer.

The technical term used here is worth learning: Hermès is a Veblen good. For most products, raising the price reduces demand. For a Veblen good the opposite happens — the higher the price, the more desirable the item becomes, because the price is part of what is being bought. That is why the waitlist exists and why it works.

Two other supports. It owns its whole supply chain, from the tanneries to the workshops, so quality is controlled in a way rivals cannot match. And its customers are the very rich, whose spending holds up in a downturn — which is why Hermès is usually the last luxury house to feel a recession and the first to come out of it.

FICO — Fair Isaac Corporation Positive

FICO owns the credit score American lenders rely on, licensing it to the three big credit bureaus — Equifax, Experian and TransUnion — and collecting a fee every time a score is pulled. It has been about as close to a legal monopoly as a private business gets.

In April the American housing regulator said it would allow a rival score, VantageScore 4.0, to be used for mortgages. The shares are now more than 55% below their peak, because the thing that made FICO safe — the rules — was the thing that changed.

Three reasons are given for thinking this is an overreaction. First, lenders who add the new score will keep pulling FICO too: in lending, having more information beats swapping one source for another. Second, decades of regulation and banks' own risk models are built around FICO, so genuinely replacing it would mean years of rebuilding systems for no obvious gain. Third, the political complaint was about price, and a score fee is trivial next to a $500,000 mortgage — what lenders actually care about is which score predicts defaults better, and FICO's newest version is still the standard.

The shares are now near their cheapest valuation in a decade, and results reported the same week were strong. The conclusion drawn: "the investment thesis is not broken after all."

QXO — QXO, Inc. Positive

QXO distributes building products — insulation, roofing, waterproofing, lumber — sitting between the manufacturers and the contractors who install them. It is barely a few years old as a serious business and is already number one or two in almost everything it sells, because it has bought its way there: more than $30 billion of acquisitions in twelve months, in an $800 billion industry.

The reason to pay attention is the man running it. Brad Jacobs has done this four times before in four different industries, and the formula is always the same. Find a large, fragmented industry full of small local firms still running on paper and phone calls. Raise a great deal of money and buy the biggest players first, so you instantly have scale and buying power nobody local can match. Then bring in technology to strip out the inefficiency — AI route planning at his trucking company XPO, centralised pricing and stock control across QXO's 1,150-plus locations.

His record: he sold United Waste Systems for $2.5 billion, built United Rentals into the world's largest equipment rental firm from nothing, and grew XPO's revenue from $175 million to $15 billion.

BLD — TopBuild Corp. Positive

TopBuild is North America's largest distributor and installer of insulation, and QXO agreed in April 2026 to buy it for $17 billion. The shares are up 444% since 2020.

The deal adds $6.2 billion of annual revenue and more than 400 locations, and management expects $300 million a year of cost savings by 2030 from combined purchasing and logistics.

The most important part is less obvious. QXO's business earns about 8 cents of operating profit per dollar of sales. TopBuild earns about 18 cents. Bolting the two together lifts the combined figure to roughly 12 cents — so QXO has improved its own profitability by buying someone else's, which is much faster than trying to squeeze more out of its existing operations. It also makes QXO the number two building-products distributor in North America overall.

Action — Action (private, held via 3i Group) Positive

Action is the European discount chain that makes up almost all of 3i Group's value. It sold €16 billion of goods in 2025 and keeps opening stores at a remarkable rate.

Two worries knocked the shares. Growth in France, its second-largest market, slowed to 2%, which made people wonder whether Europe is running out of room. And Action is spending €400 million to open in the southeastern United States from late 2027 — a move European retailers have historically got badly wrong.

The defence rests on how the business actually works. Because it buys in vast quantities, it can sell cheaply; cheap prices bring more customers; more customers mean even larger orders and lower costs, which fund lower prices again. Economists call this scale economies shared, and it is the same engine behind Amazon and Costco. One slow year in one country does not break it.


Summary derived from the archived Compounding Quality post (text in transcript.txt) for personal study. Not investment advice. © Compounding Quality / Pieter Slegers for source material.