← Analysis page  ·  Tom McClellan hub  ·  Research hub

Actionable insights — Time To Start Getting REALLY Bullish?

Not what McClellan expects, but how he builds and checks it: cycle composites, breadth studies, and time-shifted intermarket leads — written so each can be rebuilt and rerun on fresh data.
2026-SEP-17 · Thoughtful Money · Tom McClellan · ▶ Watch · full analysis · transcript
How to read this page: each insight is a method, with the boxed line showing how it played out in this episode. Headings deep-link to the moment in the video. All methods are McClellan's; the New Harbor segment (52:52 onward) is not used here.

02:29 1. Build the presidential-cycle composite yourself — and trade the dance steps, not the slope

The repeatable method
  1. Cut the index into four-year chunks starting each November 1 (election time); rebase each chunk to the same starting value.
  2. Average the chunks into one composite path; overlay the current term on an offset scale.
  3. Judge the fit by the timing of turns ("dance steps"), not by the overall slope — exogenous shocks bend the slope but the steps persist.
  4. Note how far ahead/behind schedule the market is running and shift your expected turn dates by that amount.
Here:
Term years 1–2 are "a very upward version of sideways"; the S&P is ~a week ahead of schedule in a multiple-bottom, with the year-3 climb (failed only in 1931 and 1939) about to start 05:16.
Watch for

09:47 2. Cross-check with a second, independent-looking cycle (the decennial)

The repeatable method
  1. Repeat the composite with 10-year chunks (he uses the Dow) and read the upcoming year-digit.
  2. Treat a "screwy" pattern as a hypothesis to refute with data, not to dismiss by intuition.
  3. Recognize overlap: year-6s are often presidential year 2, so the two cycles partly double-count — agreement is supportive, not independent proof.
Here:
The decennial also bottoms in early October, and the first part of year-7s is bullish (1987's crash came late in the year) 10:27.
Watch for

05:52 3. Inside a seasonal bottoming window, wait for the washout checklist

The repeatable method
  1. Once the calendar says "bottoming zone," look for: a day with a high put/call ratio, a high VIX, and breadth / breadth-momentum divergences.
  2. Require a higher low in the McClellan Oscillator (price makes a low, breadth momentum doesn't).
  3. Don't wait too long for perfection — the climb starts from the last of the multiple bottoms.
Here:
"I am not bullish today, but I am looking for the moment probably within the next week to turn bullish" 10:56.
Watch for

13:22 4. Use a new 3-year A-D high to cap the downside

The repeatable method
  1. Track the NYSE advance-decline line; flag every new 3-year high.
  2. From each flag, measure the worst drawdown in the next 3 months; the typical ceiling is ~10% (average ~4%).
  3. List the exceptions and their causes (a pandemic, an abrupt end to QE) — those are the only conditions to fear while the signal is live.
Here:
No divergence: the A-D line topped with prices, so absent a black swan the next 3 months' worst case is ~10% 14:06.
Watch for

15:37 5. Keep a separate A-D line for junk bonds as a liquidity canary

The repeatable method
  1. Maintain a daily advance-decline line for corporate high-yield bonds; they draw on the same liquidity as stocks.
  2. A bearish divergence (prices up, A-D down) is a reason an uptrend could end.
  3. Run the McClellan Oscillator on that A-D line: the deepest oscillator reading usually comes before the final price low, so an extreme reading signals the worst is being wrung out.
  4. Require junk to start improving as confirmation of the next up-leg.
Here:
A divergence all 2026 (HYG proxy), but the oscillator is "way the heck down there" — final price low likely "within a week or so" 17:05.
Watch for

20:48 6. Normalize margin debt by GDP, then time it with the seven-year cycle

The repeatable method
  1. Take FINRA monthly margin balances and divide by nominal GDP (the raw arithmetic chart exaggerates).
  2. Mark prior peaks; they tend to come shortly before important stock tops.
  3. Measure peak-to-peak spacing (~7 years; confirm on longer quarterly data back to 1945) and project the next peak date.
  4. A record level before the projected date is a warning, not a sell signal.
Here:
Record margin debt/GDP, but August 2021 + ~7 years ⇒ ~2028; "five is not seven" 24:03.
Watch for

24:44 7. Read the Fed's balance-sheet slope, not the press conference

The repeatable method
  1. Plot the Fed's combined Treasury + MBS holdings; track the slope, not just the level.
  2. A flattening slope with no announcement is stealth tightening; a turn negative is QT — the fly in a bullish liquidity backdrop.
  3. Remember his counterintuitive bond corollary: QE rounds have coincided with falling bond prices.
Here:
QE5 slope has flattened since Warsh took over, and more in the latest data; not discussed at the FOMC 25:09.
Watch for

29:06 8. Time-shift gold to forecast yields and oil

The repeatable method
  1. Plot gold and shift it forward ~20.5 months against the 30-year Treasury yield, and ~19.8 months against crude oil.
  2. Align the turns; allow slanted alignment lines where timing drifts.
  3. Use it for direction and turn timing, not magnitude (gold doubling does not mean yields double).
  4. Project the next peak: gold's top date + the lead.
Here:
Gold's run into its January-2026 top maps to a steep yield advance from late 2026 and higher oil, peaking ~August 2028 (TLT negative, Oil positive) 35:08.
Watch for

36:54 9. Read producers' hedging in the COT report

The repeatable method
  1. Pull CFTC Commitments of Traders net positions for commercials in crude futures (mostly producers hedging output).
  2. Scale the net short against its own history: a very high net short = producers happy to lock in = topping condition; a low net short = bottoming condition.
  3. Compare with price: if price is high but commercials refuse to hedge, they expect higher.
Here:
Heavy hedging into the first Iran-war spike; now, with oil above $100, commercials are "a little bit more timid" — "these experts know something" 38:18.
Watch for

Methods distilled from the public YouTube video “Time To Start Getting REALLY Bullish? | Tom McClellan” (Thoughtful Money). Not investment advice.