← Analysis page  ·  David Auerbach hub  ·  Research hub

Actionable insights — REIT Portfolio Roast

The repeatable analysis behind the grades: not which REITs he likes, but how he judges and sizes them — written so the process can be rerun on any REIT portfolio.
2026-SEP-16 · Dividend Stockpile · David Auerbach (Hoya Capital) · ▶ Watch · full analysis · transcript
How to read this page: each insight is a method — the framework he applied to Jeremy's book, and the signal to watch when re-running it. The boxed line shows how it played out in this appearance. Timestamps deep-link into the video.

3:50 1. Three buckets, with hard concentration caps

The repeatable method
  1. Sort every holding into one of three buckets: core compounders (highest-quality platforms, strong balance sheets, durable demand, many growth levers), income & value (well-covered dividend, more cost-of-capital sensitivity), contrarian / special situations.
  2. Target roughly 60 / 20 / 20 across the buckets.
  3. Cap any single property group at 20–25% of the REIT book and any single name at 8–12%.
  4. Never rank by yield alone — "who pays us the highest yield … you're going to walk into trouble with that."
Here: PLD/REG/EGP graded core; AMT slotted as the contrarian pick in an out-of-favor tower sector (11:41); the residential + industrial cluster flagged for passing the 25% cap (27:18).
Watch for

4:44 2. The per-REIT quality checklist

The repeatable method
  1. Are the assets mission-critical and scarce, in markets with durable demand?
  2. Can the balance sheet handle higher rates — fund debt maturities without issuing distressed equity?
  3. Is the dividend covered by FFO / AFFO / earnings?
  4. Where does internal growth come from: rent bumps, occupancy, development, redevelopment, operating efficiency?
  5. Then write down the specific "things to watch" for each name — the one or two risks that would break it.
Here: every grade followed the same pros → "things to watch" shape — LAMR scarce (can't build new billboards) but recession/leverage risk; EGP scarce infill but Sun Belt concentration; SUI simplifying but capital-allocation credibility unproven.
Watch for

17:43 3. Separate the business grade from the entry price

The repeatable method
  1. Grade the franchise on its own merits.
  2. Separately ask whether it trades at a premium after a strong run.
  3. A great business at a premium stays a holding but goes on the watch list for adds, rather than a fresh buy.
Here: EQIX — valuation "the biggest drawback right now … these guys have just been on a tear"; REG — "trading at a premium … something to put on a watch list, but core holding" (24:51); EGP "is rich."
Watch for

14:47 4. Read the subsector cycle from peer guidance

The repeatable method
  1. Treat each REIT subsector as sitting at its own point in the real estate cycle.
  2. Look across the whole peer group's earnings: when every company in a subsector raises guidance (or management teams uniformly say "the worst is behind us"), the subsector is turning.
  3. Add or hold the highest-quality name in that subsector rather than selling a laggard at the bottom.
Here: every hotel REIT raised guidance after Q2 → lodging "moving into the right position going into '27" (APLE); apartment managements say the Sun Belt supply glut is being absorbed → hold the laggard MAA (22:28).
Watch for

Methods distilled from the public YouTube video (transcript in transcript.txt) for personal study. Not investment advice. © Dividend Stockpile / Hoya Capital for source material.