← Analysis page  ·  David Hay hub  ·  Research hub

Actionable insights — Looking south, twice

The repeatable analysis behind the picks: not what he bought, but how he found it — written so the process can be rerun later on different countries and names.
2025-FEB-03 · Making Hay Monday (Haymaker, paid) · David Hay · ↗ Read on Haymaker · full analysis · article text
How to read this page: each insight is a method — the screen that surfaced the idea, the confirmation he demanded, and the signal to watch when re-running it. The boxed line shows how it played out in this Feb-2025 post. (A written source, so no video timestamps.)

1. The cross-country CAPE cheapness screen — rank markets, not stocks

The repeatable method
  1. Pull the Cyclically Adjusted P/E (CAPE) — earnings smoothed and inflation-adjusted over a trailing 10 years, so booms/busts don't distort it — for every major (and minor) country index.
  2. Rank them. The U.S. usually sits at the top (most expensive); look at the bottom of the list for whole markets selling cheap.
  3. Use absolute anchors: a CAPE near 10 is "deeply undervalued"; below 8 is among the cheapest in the world. That flags where to hunt before you ever pick a stock.
Here: the U.S. is at the highest CAPE among major markets; Brazil trades at a CAPE below 8 → the entire country becomes the buy candidate (expressed via EWZ).
Watch for

2. The multi-year breakout above 3-year resistance — let the chart pre-announce the turn

The repeatable method
  1. For a beaten-down country/sector, draw the horizontal ceiling it has failed to clear for at least three years.
  2. A decisive break above that line is the leading signal that the fundamental story is turning — markets often discount a reform/election outcome before it happens.
  3. Treat the breakout as permission to buy even while the news still sounds bad; don't wait for the all-clear in the headlines.
Here: the Argentina ETF (ARGT) broke above ~40 (its 3-year resistance) in early 2023 — well before Milei's November win — "a resoundingly accurate bullish signal." Haymaker's lesson from missing it: respect the breakout next time.
Watch for

3. Buy where BOTH the stocks and the currency are at fire-sale prices

The repeatable method
  1. After finding a cheap equity market, check the currency separately on a Real Effective Exchange Rate (REER) basis — how far it sits below "parity"/fair value against a trade-weighted basket.
  2. Demand a double discount: cheap stocks and a cheap currency means you can win on the equities and again on currency mean-reversion (and lose less if you're early).
Here: Brazil's Bovespa is ~8× earnings and the Real is "over 40% below parity" on REER — "one of our favorite ways to make money overseas is via countries whose stocks and currency are trading at fire-sale prices."
Watch for

4. The de-equitization / shrinking-supply tailwind — count the float

The repeatable method
  1. Check whether the market's number of listed companies is falling (buybacks, take-privates, delistings) rather than expanding via new issuance.
  2. If supply is shrinking while the market is hated, the setup is asymmetric: when money eventually returns, there's little stock to absorb it, so prices can move violently higher.
Here: Brazil has lost 13% of its listed companies since 2021 → "once the bear market ends, and money comes back... there isn't much supply around, particularly with equities."
Watch for

5. Dividend-yield-above-P/E as a deep-value flag

The repeatable method
  1. Compare a market's (or a stock's) dividend yield directly to its P/E ratio.
  2. When the dividend yield is higher than the P/E multiple, the asset is "exceedingly rare"-cheap — you're being paid an unusually large income while waiting for the re-rating.
Here: ex-Petrobras/Vale, the Bovespa yields ~9% on a ~8× P/E — "trading at a dividend return rate higher than its P/E, an exceedingly rare occurrence."
Watch for

6. Sentiment-at-GFC-intensity as the contrarian setup

The repeatable method
  1. Gauge sentiment against historical crisis extremes, not just recent averages — ask whether apathy/antipathy has reached "Global Financial Crisis intensity."
  2. Confirm with price archaeology: are valuations back at levels "only fleetingly touched in 2008/2009"? Crisis-level sentiment + crisis-level prices, absent a crisis-level reality, is the buy.
Here: per PauloMacro, sentiment toward Brazilian risk assets has hit GFC intensity and prices sit at 2008/09 levels — the basis for calling it "a once in a one- or two-generation opportunity."
Watch for

7. "Miners need the Mag-7 love affair to end first" — intermarket sequencing

The repeatable method
  1. Recognize that a sustained move in a hated sector often requires capital to rotate out of the current darling first — money is finite.
  2. Watch the leadership group (here, the Magnificent 7) for signs the love affair is ending; that rotation, not gold's price alone, is the trigger for the big miner move (the 2002 large-cap-tech-to-value analog).
  3. Until then, treat miner rallies as tradable but not yet the durable bull.
Here: Fred Hickey: "before a really big move for all the miners' stocks to happen, the investor love affair with the Magnificent 7 must end — just as occurred with large cap tech stocks in 2002." Applied to FNV, WDOFF, NGD, NEM.
Watch for

8. Trim-into-strength discipline — bank the parabola, stay in the trend

The repeatable method
  1. When a position (especially a notoriously fleveraged one like miners) goes parabolic into new highs, take partial profits rather than all-or-nothing.
  2. Be explicit about the trade-off: "trimming near highs has worked out well in the past — but there's no guarantee." Keep a core in case it's the start of a parabola.
  3. Apply it to fresh buys too: after a +25% move "be judicious with any new purchases."
Here: gold +7½% to a new ATH and overbought → Hickey is "wrestling with... profit-taking"; WDOFF up ~25% from early December → "be judicious." Both bullish and disciplined.
Watch for

9. The semiconductor double-ordering boom-bust curse — short the phantom backlog

The repeatable method
  1. In a chip up-cycle, assume reported demand is overstated: when chips are scarce, buyers double-, triple- and quadruple-order to secure allocation.
  2. Watch valuation + technicals as the timing tell (here ~37× trailing with "fragile" charts) and look for the first cracks — "earnings disappointments beginning to spread."
  3. When demand cools, the phantom orders cancel at once; even the strongest name can be "the ultimate casualty of any demand hiccup." Identify a catalyst that questions demand.
Here: the bear call on the semis and NVDA — DeepSeek flagged as the catalyst that could turn a reaction "into... a convulsion."
Watch for

Methods distilled from the paid Haymaker newsletter (text in transcript.txt) for personal study. Not investment advice. © Haymaker / David Hay for source material.