← Analysis page  ·  David Hay hub  ·  Research hub

Actionable insights — Picks of the Week (BOLSY / RYAAY + sell-discipline)

The repeatable analysis behind the picks: not what they bought, but how they found it — and, just as important, how they decide when to sell.
2026-MAY-15 · Haymaker — Friday POW! · The Haymaker Team / David Hay · ↗ Read · full analysis · article text
How to read this page: each insight is a method — a screen for what to buy, a valuation lens, or a discipline for when to take gains. The boxed line shows how it played out this week. (Written post, no video — no timestamps.)

1. The "HALO" toll-booth screen — own the infrastructure, not the cyclical underneath it

The repeatable method
  1. Look for "HALO" businesses — Hard Assets / Low Obsolescence — that sit in the same tier as payment networks and dominant software: network effects, high switching costs, structural barriers to entry.
  2. Exchange operators are the archetype: a near-monopoly that taxes a fee on every trade, with negligible incremental cost and almost no way for a competitor to enter.
  3. Confirm the historical edge: nearly every exchange with a 20-year public record has beaten its home index "by a wide margin." Use a proven peer (here NDAQ vs the Nasdaq-100) as the proof case.
  4. Prefer the toll-booth over the volatile thing it sits on (own the exchange, not just the Brazilian market) — it captures the activity in good times and bad.
Here: BOLSY (B3) — Brazil's monopoly exchange — chosen over broad Brazil exposure (EWZ); NDAQ cited as the model.
Watch for

2. The anti-fragile test — does the business get more revenue when markets panic?

The repeatable method
  1. Ask whether the company's revenue driver rises during volatility, not just during calm growth.
  2. For exchanges: trading volume rises with nominal economic growth in normal times and spikes during stress (2008: trading +25% while most businesses' profits fell ~21%).
  3. Treat that counter-cyclical revenue as a reason to size up the position in an uncertain macro regime.
Here: the anti-fragile volume profile is a core plank of the BOLSY case — it performs in both low-inflation and high-inflation regimes.
Watch for

3. Value cyclicals on Price/Sales — not P/E

The repeatable method
  1. For highly cyclical businesses (airlines among the most), earnings swing too violently to anchor a valuation — use Price/Sales instead.
  2. Find the P/S level the stock "consistently hits" across the cycle and use it as the target multiple.
  3. Compute the implied price at the through-cycle P/S; require meaningful upside to today's price.
Here: RYAAY "consistently hits 2× sales" (often 3×) → a $70 target vs $56; the same P/S-for-turnarounds logic Haymaker applies elsewhere (e.g. EL, AAP).
Watch for

4. Buy the mispriced fear — when the market punishes a risk the company already hedged away

The repeatable method
  1. When a stock falls on a macro scare (e.g. an oil-price spike), check whether the company has already neutralized that exact exposure.
  2. Read the hedge book / balance sheet: locked-in input costs and zero net debt mean the feared headwind barely lands.
  3. If the market is pricing a risk that management already removed, that gap is the opportunity.
Here: RYAAY fell $73→$56 on fuel fears, yet it hedged 70% of fuel through 2027 at $67/bbl and carries zero net debt — "unfairly punished."
Watch for

5. Separate the pretext from the fundamentals — read the operating data, not the narrative

The repeatable method
  1. When a stock is sold on a story ("AI is ending the build-out"), pull the actual operating metrics — backlog, pipeline, guidance — and see if they confirm the narrative.
  2. If the business is "firing on all cylinders" while the price falls, the weakness is "financial optics and macro fears," not a broken model.
  3. Check that no excess optimism (an "AI premium") is even priced in — if not, the downside is limited.
  4. Accumulate gradually (dollar-cost-average) rather than timing a bottom.
Here: J — sold on "the data-center boom is ending," but FY26 guidance was raised, the AI pipeline is +400% YoY and data-center work +100%, at 15× EPS / 1× sales with no AI premium → DCA in.
Watch for

6. Sell discipline — take gains when the valuation, not your conviction, has run out

The repeatable method
  1. Mark each winner against its own 5-year valuation history (P/S and P/E), not against your cost basis.
  2. When a name goes "vertical" / "quite extended" well above its historical range, trim into the strength.
  3. Distinguish two actions: take some gains on a still-good long-term story that's stretched (sell part), vs exit entirely when even the originating analyst now fears a give-back.
  4. Accept selling "too soon" (Baruch) and the tax bill as the cost of locking in a multi-bagger.
Here: COPX (+79% in 9 months, "quite extended") → take some gains; SII (a four-bagger, 29× P/E, Sy himself worried) → a rare full exit.
Watch for

7. Pair the equity with the rate cycle — falling local rates lift local equities

The repeatable method
  1. For an emerging-market equity, check the direction of local interest rates: rates falling from "incredibly lofty levels" is a direct multiple tailwind.
  2. Confirm the real (after-inflation) yield is still attractive (so bonds also work) and that rates have further to fall.
  3. Buy the equity into the easing cycle, accepting EM-specific risks (currency, politics) as the price of the discount.
Here: Brazilian 10-yr real yields ~14% nominal / ~9% real, seen falling toward 10% — the tailwind behind both the bonds and BOLSY/EWZ.
Watch for

Methods distilled from the paid Haymaker newsletter (text in transcript.txt) for personal study. Not investment advice. © Haymaker / David Hay for source material.